Market Roundups

Add as a preferred source on Google

ECB expert says luxury goods do not generate investment income

Luxury goods do not generate income for their owners, unlike assets such as stocks and bonds, a European Central Bank expert said.

Updated 2 min read
European Central Bank broadcast. (Screen grab)
European Central Bank broadcast. (Screen grab)

Luxury goods do not generate income for their owners as stocks and bonds can, a European Central Bank expert said in a video published on Nov. 18.

The distinction means a luxury item's investment value depends largely on whether another buyer will pay more for it. A higher resale price is not guaranteed, and finding a buyer can take time.

In the video, “I Compared Luxury Investing to Stocks (Here’s What Won),” the central bank examined handbags and watches alongside conventional investments.

Bag Hunter, a luxury reseller, found in a 2016 study that Birkin bags returned an average of roughly 14% a year between 1980 and 2015. The study put the annual return for the S&P 500 index, which tracks 500 stocks, at about 9%.

The comparison used data from a time when the resale market was much smaller. It also compared one type of handbag with a broad stock index.

Over the past decade, the average resale price of Birkin bags rose more than 92%. The video did not identify the source of that figure.

A new standard Birkin retailed for about 9,600 euros in early 2026. But access to new bags is limited, and some customers may spend tens of thousands of euros on other goods before being offered one.

On the resale market, Birkin bags can sell for double or triple their retail price, and sometimes more. The price paid to acquire a bag can therefore differ considerably from its price in a shop.

Other luxury goods have also commanded higher prices after leaving stores. Patek Philippe stopped making its Nautilus 5711 watch in 2021, and resale prices tripled almost overnight.

The central bank expert said stocks, bonds and property can produce economic value and generate income. Stocks can pay dividends, bonds can pay interest, and property can generate rent.

Luxury goods are non-productive assets, meaning they do not generate income simply by being held. Gold also falls into that category, the expert said.

Fashion and demand can change, leaving an owner with a loss. Scratches, stains and other damage can also reduce the price a buyer will pay.

Counterfeit goods can enter the resale market, even though many auction houses and sellers have established reputations for selling authentic products. The video did not give a forecast for luxury resale prices or identify which goods would gain value.

Related articles

View all