Law / Politics

Add as a preferred source on Google

European Court Orders Türkiye to Release Lawmaker Can Atalay

The seven-judge chamber found four violations of the European Convention on Human Rights and ordered €32,500 in damages. Its judgment is not yet final.

Updated 2 min read
Visitors approach the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg under gray skies. / EconoTimes.ai
Visitors approach the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg under gray skies. / EconoTimes.ai

A European human-rights court ordered Türkiye to free lawmaker Şerafettin Can Atalay and let him take his seat in Parliament, centering the case on whether domestic courts must honor Constitutional Court rulings.

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) found violations of four protections in the European Convention on Human Rights: freedom from unlawful detention, access to a review of detention, free elections and limits on restrictions imposed for improper purposes. The seven-judge chamber adopted three findings by six votes to one; all seven judges agreed on the detention-review violation. The court said Atalay’s continued detention was meant to silence him and suppress political pluralism.

A Turkish court sentenced Atalay to 18 years in prison on Apr. 25, 2022, in the Gezi Park case. He won a seat representing Hatay in the May 14, 2023, election while his appeal was pending. Türkiye’s Constitutional Court found rights violations on Oct. 25, 2023, then issued a second ruling on Dec. 21 after the first had not been enforced. The Court of Cassation declined to apply those decisions, and Atalay’s parliamentary mandate ended Jan. 30, 2024.

The ECHR said the failure to carry out the Constitutional Court’s rulings left Atalay without an effective review that could lead to his release and prevented voters’ choice from being represented in Parliament. The court also cited earlier cases involving detained political opponents, human-rights defenders and journalists in which authorities had failed to implement constitutional remedies. It described the second refusal in Atalay’s case as unprecedented.

The court ordered Türkiye to end Atalay’s detention, release him immediately and restore his ability to serve as a lawmaker. It also directed authorities to take steps to ensure Constitutional Court decisions are fully implemented and ordered payment of €32,500 for non-pecuniary damage.

The chamber judgment is not final. Either side may request referral to the ECHR Grand Chamber within three months of the decision. If the ruling becomes final, the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers will supervise its execution.

Related articles

View all