Politics / Technology

Add as a preferred source on Google

Singapore Researcher Urges Stronger Focus on Information Resilience

CNA Verify reported nearly 400 posts across five platforms and found coordination signs among some accounts; Nicholas Fang said their director and agenda could not be confirmed.

Updated 2 min read
A commuter checks a smartphone near Parliament House in Singapore's Civic District on an overcast morning. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)
A commuter checks a smartphone near Parliament House in Singapore's Civic District on an overcast morning. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)

A Singapore researcher has urged officials to treat information resilience as a distinct national-security priority after online claims tied the city-state to Indonesia's market dispute and haze response.

Channel NewsAsia's CNA Verify unit said it tracked almost 400 posts on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, X and Facebook from Oct. 19 to Oct. 27. The posts accumulated views close to 12 million and included claims linking Singapore to Indonesia's market difficulties, as well as a story about a diplomatic meeting that never took place. CNA Verify found signs of coordination among some accounts, but its reporting did not show that they answered to a single operator.

The posts circulated as MSCI Inc., a global index provider, reviewed Indonesia's market classification. On Oct. 15, MSCI began consulting on a proposal to move its Indonesia indexes from emerging-market to standalone-market status. It pointed to difficulty seeing who owns some shares, suspected trading coordination and doubts about the effectiveness of enforcement. MSCI plans to decide by June 30, 2027, after receiving feedback through April 30.

CNA Verify reported that former Indonesian Trade Minister Muhammad Lutfi alleged Singapore state investors GIC and Temasek influenced MSCI. In a Nov. 3 parliamentary reply, Singapore Second Minister for Finance Jeffrey Siow rejected the allegation and said both institutions had publicly denied seeking to influence the index provider. The Indonesia Stock Exchange said Oct. 16 that it respected MSCI's independent review process.

In a Nov. 18 Channel NewsAsia commentary, Nicholas Fang, founder and managing director of Black Dot Research, said the available evidence did not confirm who directed the online activity or what its agenda was. Fang warned that the claims could confuse people about Singapore's response to haze and damage the country's reputation if the allegations about MSCI gained traction. Those are risks he identified, not measured effects of the posts.

Fang proposed giving information resilience a distinct place in Singapore's Total Defence framework. Introduced in 1984, the framework has six pillars, including digital and psychological defense. His proposal was not a government policy announcement.

Singapore's Foreign Affairs Ministry said Singapore and Indonesia agreed on Oct. 27 to set up a joint group to exchange information and coordinate work on haze crossing national borders. MSCI's consultation remains open through April 30, 2027, with the provider's decision due by June 30.

Related articles

View all