Law

Add as a preferred source on Google

UK Tribunal Dismisses £1.97 Billion PlayStation Digital-Content Claim Against Sony

The case alleged exclusionary conduct and excessive prices on behalf of about 12.2 million UK consumers.

Updated 2 min read
A pedestrian passes the Competition Appeal Tribunal at Salisbury Square House in London. / EconoTimes.ai
A pedestrian passes the Competition Appeal Tribunal at Salisbury Square House in London. / EconoTimes.ai

Britain’s Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed a £1.971 billion claim against Sony over PlayStation digital games and add-on sales, rejecting a case brought for about 12.2 million UK consumers.

In its Nov. 17 judgment, the tribunal said Alex Neill Class Representative Limited had not proved that Sony infringed competition law. The decision turned in part on whether Sony’s console hardware and digital sales should be assessed together as a broader gaming systems market.

The class representative alleged that Sony used exclusive dealing, tying and refusals to supply to limit rival distribution, while charging excessive and unfair prices. It argued that digital content would have cost about 20% less without the alleged conduct. The tribunal said physical PlayStation games were likely substitutes for digital titles and that consumers’ ability to use multiple platforms and buy across them could constrain Sony.

The judgment described Sony’s business model as accepting low or negative margins on console sales and recovering value through games, add-on content and subscriptions. The tribunal said that supported assessing the business at the systems level. Even if the class representative’s narrower market definition were used, the tribunal found it had not established the lower-price scenario, excessive or unfair margins, or the conditions required for its refusal-to-supply claim.

The proposed class covered buyers of digital content on PlayStation consoles in the UK from Aug. 19, 2016, for people domiciled in England and Wales, or Aug. 19, 2017, for people domiciled in Scotland, through Feb. 12, 2026. The claim sought about £1.490 billion in damages, plus simple interest at 8% a year, for a total of approximately £1.971 billion. The tribunal dismissed the claim in full and awarded no damages.

The proceedings were filed Aug. 22, 2022, and the Collective Proceedings Order was made on Jan. 19, 2024; trial ran from March 10 to May 8, 2026.

Related articles

View all