The Heritage Foundation’s chief economist, EJ Antoni, backed selling older Nvidia chips to China while withholding the newest technology to preserve America’s advantage in artificial intelligence, he said in an interview.
Antoni said export restrictions risked helping Chinese competitors grow if they removed foreign competition. He also called for an investigation into who knew about efforts to bypass US controls and when.
Speaking on Fox Business in a recording published Nov. 16, Antoni described chip export policy as “a bit of a balancing act”. He argued that restrictions needed to preserve American manufacturing strength alongside its technological advantage.
He cited Huawei as an example of the risks of cutting off competition. Antoni said the Chinese government had poured money into the company after export controls reduced outside competition, helping it develop technology and expand.
His preferred approach would allow China to buy chips one or two generations behind the newest products. The fastest, most powerful and most efficient technology would not necessarily be available for sale to China under that approach.
“We want the rest of the world to be dependent on America,” Antoni said. He applied that argument to both chips and steel, saying American manufacturers could supply overseas buyers while the United States retained its advantage in artificial intelligence.
Asked whether the controversy could bring political consequences for Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Antoni said that was very likely, though not guaranteed. He then described Treasury efforts to identify companies using the secondhand market to get around restrictions.
Antoni said intermediaries bought chips in Singapore and elsewhere in Southeast Asia and resold them to China. Another route involved keeping chips in facilities outside China and renting access to their computing power to Chinese users.
Under that arrangement, Chinese artificial intelligence models could run on servers elsewhere in Southeast Asia while still using the chips’ capabilities. Antoni said Nvidia had taken some steps to stop such activity, but the Commerce Department had not done enough.
Turning to responsibility for enforcement, Antoni supported an investigation to establish what those involved knew and when they learned it. He did not identify specific people who should face investigation or set out how an inquiry should proceed.
He also distinguished Nvidia’s responsibilities from policing the entire resale market. Antoni said the company had made good-faith efforts in some cases, including pressing artificial intelligence companies outside China over the last year to remove Chinese board members and certain Chinese investors.
Those efforts sought to limit Chinese influence over the companies, he said. Antoni rejected a blanket characterization of Nvidia’s conduct as bad faith, leaving his criticism of government enforcement alongside support for some of the company’s actions.



