In a Nov. 15 Econbrowser analysis, Menzie Chinn argued that Germany’s falling employment and hours worked did not establish a recession while output kept rising, leaving analysts with competing signals.
Chinn compared dates from ECRI, the German Council of Economic Experts and Laurent Ferrara with a separate chronology based on employment. He said that employment series draws mostly on national accounts, with a smaller contribution from household survey data.
Chinn described Ferrara’s 2019 chronology as dating peaks with the Bry and Broschan algorithm using GDP and industrial-production data. Because Ferrara’s chronology predates the pandemic, Chinn assumed ECRI’s 2020 dates would match Ferrara’s in his comparison.
A chart in the analysis tracks real GDP, employment, hours worked and industrial production, with the series shown in log terms relative to 2024Q2=0. Chinn cited OECD data via FRED, the ECB and his own calculations as sources for the chart.
The latest ifo nowcast cited in the post, dated Nov. 6, put fourth-quarter growth at 0.62% quarter over quarter.


