The U.S. Justice Department asked a federal appeals court Thursday, Nov. 19, to dismiss its challenge to Alaska’s Senate election after Democrat Mary Peltola won the race outright, removing the condition at the center of the lawsuit.
In a filing to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Justice Department attorneys argued that the case is now moot because Peltola secured a majority and will become the Democratic Party’s 56th senator. They asked the court to set aside the lower court’s ruling and return the case for dismissal on mootness grounds.
Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., who appeared on the ballot without a party preference. The administration had sought to delay certification while investigators examined whether voters might have confused the two candidates with similar names.
The lawsuit’s conditional request would have paused certification if counting votes for Daniel Sullivan Jr. as votes for the incumbent could have changed the result under Alaska’s ranked-choice system, according to earlier EconoTimes coverage of the case.
The Alaska Supreme Court previously ruled that Daniel Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy was lawful. Attorneys for Alaska also opposed the Justice Department’s position and described the administration’s move as legally “meritless” in court papers.
Peltola said the election should close the dispute. “I’m eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans,” she said.
The appeals court’s action on the Justice Department’s request will determine how the federal case is formally closed.



