Law

Add as a preferred source on Google

Lucy Letby Lawyer Seeks Review Citing Undisclosed Expert Restrictions

Mark McDonald applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, arguing the jury should have heard about developments involving prosecution witness Peter Hindmarsh.

Updated 2 min read
The Royal Courts of Justice stands beneath an overcast sky in London, England (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)
The Royal Courts of Justice stands beneath an overcast sky in London, England (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)

A lawyer for Lucy Letby has asked the Criminal Cases Review Commission to examine her convictions, saying jurors were not told about professional restrictions on a prosecution expert who testified about two babies, The Guardian reported.

Mark McDonald filed the application with the commission, which can refer cases to the Court of Appeal. He argues that the jury should have been informed about developments concerning medical expert Peter Hindmarsh, the newspaper reported.

University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust barred Hindmarsh from clinical practice in March 2023 over concerns about risks to child patients, according to The Guardian. At Letby’s trial, he testified that two babies had been poisoned with insulin. Letby was convicted of attempting to murder those two babies.

In April 2023, a medical practitioners tribunal ordered that Hindmarsh be directly supervised in his clinical work, The Guardian reported. The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said it had not received information about either the March restriction or the tribunal order.

Hindmarsh told Cheshire police in December 2022 that he was under investigation by the General Medical Council, The Guardian reported. The CPS disclosed the investigation to Letby’s defense team but opposed informing the jury, according to the newspaper. Jurors did not hear about the investigation or the later developments.

Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others. The Court of Appeal has rejected her applications to appeal, The Guardian reported.

Two senior lawyers told The Guardian that serious concerns about an expert’s professional ability, coupled with nondisclosure to the defense, could provide grounds for an appeal. Tim Green KC said the significance would depend on how the information could have affected the jury’s assessment. Hindmarsh’s representative and Cheshire police declined to comment to the newspaper; the CPS confirmed it had not received the information.

Related articles

View all