Law

Add as a preferred source on Google

Massachusetts Court To Review Clancy Bid To Block Possible Retrial

The full seven-member Supreme Judicial Court is expected to hear arguments in January 2027 after Lindsay Clancy’s first murder trial ended in a mistrial.

Updated 2 min read
Lawyers approach Plymouth Superior Court in Massachusetts during proceedings over a possible retrial. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)
Lawyers approach Plymouth Superior Court in Massachusetts during proceedings over a possible retrial. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will weigh whether prosecutors may retry Lindsay Clancy after jurors deadlocked, as her appeal challenges a second trial scheduled for March 2027.

Justice Elizabeth Dewar reserved the case for the court’s full seven-member bench. Arguments are expected in January 2027, although no exact date has been announced.

Clancy’s lawyers filed a petition under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 211, Section 3, after Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan rejected her request to dismiss the case Nov. 9. Sullivan’s ruling found that the jury’s inability to reach a unanimous verdict created a legally sufficient basis for a mistrial and possible retrial. EconoTimes previously reported on Sullivan’s decision to keep the case eligible for a retrial.

The proceedings ran for 26 days. Jurors heard from 90 witnesses and examined 300 exhibits before deliberating roughly 27 hours across four days. Sullivan declared the mistrial Sept. 4, 2026.

The appeal focuses on two notes written by the jury foreperson. The defense says the first indicated that a juror could not follow the reasonable-doubt instructions and that a later note showed the juror acknowledged doubt but refused to apply it to the verdict. Sullivan said the notes did not reliably establish that the juror was unable or unwilling to deliberate or follow the law.

Clancy’s lawyers argue Sullivan should have questioned the foreperson and the disputed juror more extensively or considered removing the juror. They say another prosecution would violate the constitutional protection against double jeopardy. Their petition states that a second trial scheduled for March 29, 2027, would violate Clancy’s rights.

Sullivan wrote that additional questioning risked intruding on confidential deliberations or pressuring the dissenting juror. He described a hung jury as a traditional example of “manifest necessity” that permits a retrial and concluded that the mistrial did not trigger a double-jeopardy bar.

In a Commonwealth filing, Assistant Plymouth County District Attorney Melissa Johnsen wrote that Sullivan used every available approach to address the notes without coercing jurors or exposing private deliberations. Defense attorney Martin Weinberg told WBUR that the appeal will examine whether a defendant is protected from the “perils and burdens” of a second trial.

Clancy faces three murder indictments over the 2023 deaths of her children at the family’s home in Duxbury, Massachusetts. Her defense has argued that postpartum psychosis made her not criminally responsible; prosecutors contend she planned the killings and understood her actions.

The Supreme Judicial Court’s ruling will determine whether the prosecution can proceed toward the scheduled March 29 jury selection.

Related articles

View all