Law / Health

Add as a preferred source on Google

New South Wales Inquest Examines Four Infant Deaths After Freebirths and Home Birth

Evidence includes testimony about a newborn who died hours after a freebirth near Byron Bay, amid differing accounts of the care he received.

Updated 2 min read
A home stands on a quiet residential street near Byron Bay, New South Wales. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)
A home stands on a quiet residential street near Byron Bay, New South Wales. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)

A New South Wales inquest into four infant deaths is examining decisions around freebirths and home births, along with barriers to health services that may shape families’ choices.

ABC News reported that proceedings began Monday, Nov. 16, and were expected to run for two weeks. The cases include three freebirths in northern New South Wales and one home birth in the Hunter Valley. Counsel assisting the coroner said the inquiry was not intended to blame parents for their choices. ABC distinguishes a freebirth, which takes place without medical assistance, from a home birth attended by a registered midwife.

One case concerns Baby DH, born during a freebirth at his parents’ home near Byron Bay. The Guardian reported that Baby DH lived for just over eight hours and was declared dead at the hospital. His parents told the inquest Amy Lou Smith, their doula, reassured them while the baby appeared limp, discolored and short of breath. They said Smith left as they sought medical help to prepare a jumping castle for her son’s birthday, The Guardian reported.

Smith said she understood the parents had accepted her departure and that the castle was ready. She testified that she expected them to seek emergency help if they believed Baby DH was seriously ill, and denied giving clinical advice, according to The Guardian. Smith also said she had no medical training and had not been taught to assess a newborn’s color, breathing or feeding. She said she had attended 15 births over four years, nine alongside a midwife.

The inquest heard that neonatologist Dr. Paul Evans found Baby DH had a complex heart defect detectable by X-ray and that it could have been treated. The Guardian reported that Evans’s findings said his death was not inevitable.

ABC reported that expert midwives linked some women’s decisions to choose freebirths with distrust of clinicians. The inquiry is also examining the support families received and barriers to engaging with health services, ABC reported.

Related articles

View all