The California Court of Appeal affirmed a 2016 verdict finding Oracle liable for $3 billion for violating agreements on settlement and software development with Hewlett-Packard Co.
The 2010 settlement resolved a trade secrets case brought by HP after its former CEO Mike Hurd was hired by Oracle.
Furthermore, Oracle breached a provision in the agreement requiring it to continue to offer its software on HP’s Itanium server platform.
Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co spokesperson Adam Bauer said they were "incredibly pleased" with the ruling.
Justice Allison Danner wrote for a three-judge panel, affirming a 2016 jury verdict.
HP sued Oracle in California state court in 2011 for its alleged refusal to continue offering its software months after the breach and trade secret settlement based on its hiring of Hurd.
A 2012 ruling favored HP, saying that Oracle under the agreement should continue offering the products until HP stopped selling Itanium-based servers.
A Santa Clara, California jury awarded HP over $3 billion in damages in 2016.
On appeal, Oracle argued that the agreement merely restates the voluntary, non-contractual relationship between the two firms.
But Danner and Justices Mary Greenwood and Franklin Elia said that based on the agreement's plain language, the parties' previous dealing, and the surrounding circumstances required Oracle to continue to offer its products as long as HP continued to sell the platform.
Danner also upheld the jury award that included lost profits based on an expert opinion on HP's potential market share loss.
Hewlett-Packard was represented by a Gibson Dunn & Crutcher team led by Theodore Boutros. The firm didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.
Meanwhile, Margaret Grignon of the Grignon Law Firm and Sadik Huseny of Latham & Watkins represented Oracle.


Gold Prices Edge Higher as Markets Await Key U.S. PCE Inflation Data
BOJ Governor Ueda Highlights Uncertainty Over Future Interest Rate Hikes
Vietnam’s November Trade Sees Monthly Decline but Strong Year-on-Year Growth
Key Witness Seeks to Block Evidence in Potential Revival of Comey Case
Bolsonaro Blames Medication Mix-Up for Ankle Monitor Tampering as Detention Continues
European Stocks Rise as Markets Await Key U.S. Inflation Data
Citi Sets Bullish 2026 Target for STOXX 600 as Fiscal Support and Monetary Easing Boost Outlook
Union Urges Court to Compel Trump Administration to Restore CFPB Funding
Asian Currencies Edge Higher as Markets Look to Fed Rate Cut; Rupee Steadies Near Record Lows
Northwestern University to Restore Research Funding Under $75 Million Agreement with U.S. Government
U.S. Justice Department Orders Intensified Probe Into Antifa and Domestic Extremist Groups
Dollar Slides to Five-Week Low as Asian Stocks Struggle and Markets Bet on Fed Rate Cut
Spain’s Industrial Output Records Steady Growth in October Amid Revised September Figures
Peru’s Ex-President Martín Vizcarra Sentenced to 14 Years in Prison for Corruption
Singapore Court Allows $2.7 Billion 1MDB Lawsuit Against Standard Chartered to Proceed
Amazon Italy Pays €180M in Compensation as Delivery Staff Probe Ends
Bristol Myers Faces $6.7 Billion Lawsuit After Judge Allows Key Shareholder Claims to Proceed 



