Law / Business

Add as a preferred source on Google

South Korea’s Supreme Court Requires Proof Companies Benefited From Store Music

The cases involve music played at T’station and LG Best Shop locations, with the Korea Music Copyright Association seeking payment in both disputes.

Updated 2 min read
Visitors climb the steps of the Supreme Court of Korea in Seoul. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)
Visitors climb the steps of the Supreme Court of Korea in Seoul. (AI-generated image / EconoTimes)

The Korea Herald reported that South Korea’s Supreme Court narrowed when firms can be ordered to surrender gains tied to unlicensed store music, requiring proof the company itself benefited. The justices set aside lower-court rulings on Oct. 27 and sent the Hankook Tire & Technology and LG Electronics disputes back for review, the Herald reported.

The cases address who may be held financially responsible when music is played at outlets operated by franchisees or a subsidiary. The Korea Music Copyright Association sought payment in both disputes, according to the Herald.

In the LG dispute, the association sought 267.92 million won for music played at LG Best Shop stores from 2014 to 2016, the report said. Lower courts initially ruled for LG under a copyright exception for recordings made for sale. An earlier Supreme Court ruling found the recordings were made for in-store use and fell outside that exception, according to the Herald. The Seoul High Court later awarded the association about 40 million won. After both parties appealed, the Supreme Court said any subsidiary operating LG stores was a separate legal entity and found insufficient evidence that LG Electronics itself benefited, the report said.

The Hankook case concerns music played in T’station company-operated and franchised stores from 2009 to 2016. The association sued in 2020, seeking 146.92 million won, about $110,000, and arguing that providers’ permission to webcast songs did not cover in-store use, according to the Herald. Earlier courts found the damages claim was filed too late but still ordered Hankook to repay about 9.42 million won. They viewed franchise recruitment and higher fee income as indirect benefits from the music, the report said.

The Supreme Court held that franchisees were responsible for playing music in their stores and said the association needed evidence of a concrete benefit to Hankook itself, the Herald reported. The case was returned to Seoul Central District Court to consider whether franchisees paid Hankook for the music service or whether the music helped it attract franchisees or collect higher fees.

Related articles

View all