UK Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has drawn attention to Birmingham’s rapidly expanding supported exempt accommodation sector after a review reported more than £615 million in housing-benefit payments across a 12-month period beginning April 2024 and a separate four-month period beginning April 2026.
The Guardian reported that Mahmood, who represents Birmingham Ladywood, said she “smells a rat” in remarks made to the Birmingham Mail. The Guardian said the city had more than 34,000 residents across about 12,200 properties, figures that were reported from a council review.
That review recorded £404.4 million in payments during the year beginning April 2024 and another £211.8 million over four months from April 2026, The Guardian reported. It also identified 12,700 live cases awaiting checks that care, support and supervision were being delivered after tenancies began.
The accommodation model covers homes where residents receive support or supervision, including people recovering from addiction, former prisoners and women escaping domestic abuse. Because of those support needs, the homes are exempt from standard housing-benefit caps.
A Department for Work and Pensions response cited in a UK Parliament written answer put Birmingham’s supported exempt accommodation expenditure at £379 million in 2024-25 and £508 million in 2025-26. The department said robust data was unavailable for 2023-24 and that overpayment and recovery figures were not readily available.
Birmingham City Council has described the sector as largely unregulated for years. The council said that allowed some providers to seek payment for support that was not delivered and left some residents in poor-quality housing. Local authorities administer and scrutinize Housing Benefit, while the central government finances it.
Under the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023, the government is preparing a licensing system and national standards for supported housing. Planned measures include a fit-and-proper-person test and a link between licensing and Housing Benefit eligibility; implementation is estimated for 2027-28.
The Supported Housing Advisory Panel described Birmingham as having a “very high level” of supported exempt accommodation. A ministerial roundtable involving the council, government departments, regulators and lawmakers was held in July 2026.
The Regulator of Social Housing opened an independent inquiry Nov. 3 into Ash-Shahada Housing Association Limited, a Birmingham provider. The inquiry will examine possible conflicts of interest, governance weaknesses and the use of housing assets.



