The Financial Conduct Authority said preliminary data show UK persistent-debt rates rising again, complicating its assessment of 2018 rules after the share of credit card accounts in the category fell to 3% by early 2023.
The FCA’s evaluation put the share at 7% in 2018 and said consumer outcomes improved by early 2023. But incomplete company records and broader changes, including the COVID-19 pandemic, the cost-of-living crisis and higher interest rates, limited the regulator’s ability to determine how much the rules contributed. The figures cover UK accounts and do not establish a wider international trend.
The rules apply when, over 18 months, a customer’s payments toward the principal are smaller than the account’s interest, fees and charges. Among other exceptions, the FCA Handbook excludes accounts whose balances were below £200 at any point in that period. Lenders must contact customers at 18 months, send another notice at 27 months when a customer appears likely to remain in persistent debt at 36 months, and offer repayment options at 36 months.
In the FCA’s analysis, 53% of consumers who received an initial 18-month letter had left persistent debt within 18 months; the share reached 65% within 27 months. Customer-level data came from 10 lenders. For accounts in persistent debt that accrued interest, average monthly interest fell from £74 to £63 by March 2023. The evaluation states that its monetary figures are in 2026 prices.
The regulator’s 2016 credit card market study found about 5.6 million people were potentially in problematic debt. The FCA said persistent debt can be profitable for lenders, weakening their incentive to address it, while consumers face high borrowing costs. Its earlier estimates projected lower interest costs for consumers and a corresponding loss of interest revenue for firms; those were forecasts, not measured outcomes.
The FCA estimated firms’ compliance costs at £281.6 million. Seven firms supplied cost information, and the regulator estimated they represented 43% of the market; it used their reports to calculate the wider cost. The evaluation says that figure was slightly below the FCA’s earlier estimate of £294.6 million to £334.1 million.
In a Nov. 18 blog, FCA Director of Consumer Finance Alison Walters said, “Credit card use and defaults have increased since the period covered by the evaluation.” The blog said newer product-sales data point to higher persistent-debt rates, but gave no rate or period for the increase. Walters said customers unable to afford higher repayments may need broader help, such as reduced interest, fees or charges and referrals to free debt advice. The FCA plans to monitor the rates using product-sales data collected from firms.


