Law / Business

Add as a preferred source on Google

Xiaomi, Flextronics Challenge India’s Customs Treatment of Phone Royalties

A customs tribunal found Xiaomi India responsible for including technology royalties in the value of parts imported by contract manufacturers. Reuters reported that India is seeking dismissal of the appeals.

Updated 2 min read
Visitors enter the Supreme Court of India in New Delhi under an overcast afternoon sky. / EconoTimes.ai (mono)
Visitors enter the Supreme Court of India in New Delhi under an overcast afternoon sky. / EconoTimes.ai (mono)

India’s Supreme Court appeals over Xiaomi’s phone-component royalties could determine whether licensing payments add to customs duties, after a tribunal found Xiaomi India to be the beneficial owner of the imported parts.

Reuters reported that India has asked the court to dismiss appeals by Xiaomi Technology India Pvt. Ltd. and Flextronics Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. In Reuters’ account, a Sept. 21 government filing said Xiaomi provided customs officials with its licensing agreements only after investigators began an inquiry. Reuters also reported that a Sept. 11 filing argued Flextronics had not presented its contractual arrangements to customs officials.

The dispute is whether technology licensing fees should be counted when customs authorities value phone components. In November 2025, the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) found Xiaomi India to be the beneficial owner of parts imported by contract manufacturers and included royalties and license fees in the value used to calculate customs duty. It upheld the additional duty and interest, while sending penalties back for a new calculation. The ruling covered imports from April 1, 2017, through June 30, 2020, and involved four contract manufacturers, including Flextronics.

Xiaomi’s position, as Reuters reported it, is that contract manufacturers imported the components and royalty payments were separate. The dispute turns on whether Xiaomi’s licensing arrangements make those payments part of the customs value despite manufacturers handling the imports. Potential costs fall on Xiaomi through duties and on contract manufacturers through penalties, which remain subject to recalculation. Reuters estimated Xiaomi India’s potential exposure at more than $150 million; that estimate is not a final liability set by the court.

Reuters also cited experts who said the case could bring greater scrutiny to contract manufacturing in pharmaceuticals, autos and other industries that use the model.

A Supreme Court registrar’s Sept. 9 order recorded Xiaomi’s appeals as C.A. Nos. 876-877/2026 and Flextronics’ as C.A. No. 1475/2026. The registrar set Sept. 30 as the deadline for objections to applications to add parties, after which the appeals were to be processed for listing.

Related articles

View all