CNA and The Straits Times reported that 54% of households leaving Singapore’s ComCare Short-to-Medium-Term Assistance (SMTA) in 2022 returned within three years, citing a Ministry of Social and Family Development trends report.
The outlets put the rate at 49% for households that left in 2021 and 63% for the 2019 group. The reports said 50% of the 2022 group returned within two years and 43% within one year. For the 2021 group, the respective shares were 46% and 38%. Most households that returned within three years did so in the first 12 months after exit.
Employment outcomes differed between the groups. In 2023, at least one member had stable employment in 46% of non-returning households, compared with 35% among those that returned. CNA reported that MSF’s threshold for stable employment was at least six consecutive months of work during a year.
CNA also reported that non-returning households worked a median of 17 months over the three years after exit, compared with 11 months among returning households.
Caregiving and health indicators also differed. Among households that returned, 23% had a beneficiary aged six or younger when assistance ended, versus 16% of non-returners. The primary beneficiary was medically unfit for work in 18% of returning households, compared with 13% of households that stayed off assistance.
These figures describe differences between groups; they do not establish that stable employment prevented a return. MSF told CNA that a household returning to the scheme may have been ready to leave assistance earlier, before later changes in employment, health or caregiving responsibilities.
MSF describes SMTA as temporary help with basic living needs. The scheme serves people unable to work for a period because of illness or caregiving, job seekers and low-income earners.
In a 2025 release, MSF said the three-year return rate had fallen from 61% for the 2018 exit group to 49% in 2021. It linked the lower figure partly to a larger share of first-time recipients who received help during the COVID-19 economic disruption and were generally more self-reliant.



