The 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that six Chinese banks weren't liable for $150 million in sanctions due to the failure of Next Investments LLC to freeze the assets of hundreds of Nike counterfeiters.
Next, which acquired the $1.8 billion default award from Nike Inc, had failed to enforce the freeze against the banks for nearly six years before asking the court to hold them in contempt, said US Circuit Judge Michael Park for a unanimous three-judge panel.
In 2015, Nike and its Converse Inc unit won the default judgment against over 600 Chinese entities and individuals in the Manhattan federal court.
US District Judge Shira Scheindlin also restrained the defendants and everyone acting in concert or in participation with them from transferring their assets.
Nike sold its interest in the judgment to Houston-based Next Investments LLC in 2017.
Next subpoenaed six Chinese banks with New York branches where the counterfeiters allegedly had accounts and filed contempt charges against them in 2019 for failing to comply with the asset restraining orders, asking $150 million in compensatory damages.
Senior US District Judge Colleen McMahon rejected Next's motion in 2020 as US branches of foreign banks are separate legal entities.
The separate entity rule also kept the court from enforcing the freeze as to assets in China.
On appeal, Next insisted that the separate entity rule shouldn't enable counterfeiting, among other things.
Park, Senior Circuit Judge Jon Newman, and Circuit Judge Steven Menashi declined to hold the banks in contempt or enforce the order.
On top of its failure to enforce the orders against the banks for nearly six years, Nike and Next "explicitly disclaimed" that they would invoke the ruling against four of the banks.
The court also said that there was a "fair ground of doubt" about the orders' applicability to the banks due to the separate entity rule.
Adam Hoffinger, who represented the Agricultural Bank of China, said the decision reaffirmed that his client had done nothing wrong.


Kennedy Center Ordered to Remove Trump Name Following Federal Court Ruling
Trump and Iran Sign Framework Peace Deal in France Amid Ongoing Middle East Tensions
Australia Eases Capital Gains Tax Reforms to Support Small Businesses and Startups
Judge Dismisses Trump Administration Lawsuit Against Boston Sanctuary City Policy
Meta Seeks Legal Shield From Child-Harm Lawsuits Amid KOSA Talks
US Stock Futures Slip After Wall Street Rally Fueled by US-Iran Deal and Chipmaker Surge
Dollar Hits One-Month High as Hawkish Fed Outlook Boosts Greenback
U.S. Reinstates Sanctions on U.N. Expert Francesca Albanese Amid Legal Battle
Gold Prices Slide as Hawkish Fed and Strong Dollar Weigh on Bullion
Biden Sues DOJ to Block Release of Audio From Classified Documents Probe
Italy’s Economy Outpaces Eurozone Peers as Investment Spending Fuels Growth
BOJ Signals More Rate Hikes as Inflation Risks Rise Amid Energy Price Pressures
Bayer Rules Out Monsanto Spin-Off as Roundup Lawsuits Continue to Mount
Sable Offshore Wins Key Court Battle Over California Oil Pipeline
DOJ Clears Paramount Skydance-Warner Bros. Discovery Merger Without Conditions
U.S. Supreme Court to Review Trump Administration Appeal on Immigrant Detention Without Bond Hearings
Dollar Surges After Fed Holds Rates Steady, Signals Potential Tightening Ahead 



