Sen. John Cornyn said he would withhold a required Senate blue slip for President Donald Trump’s nominee T. Elliot Gaiser, blocking his path to a committee hearing for a seat on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas.
The Senate record lists Gaiser, who is from Ohio, as Trump’s nominee for the vacancy left by Judge Jane J. Boyle’s retirement. Under the Senate Judiciary Committee’s current policy for district court nominees, both home-state senators must return positive blue slips for a nominee to receive a hearing, CBS News reported. Gaiser was not among the seven judicial nominees who appeared at the committee’s Nov. 18 hearing.
Cornyn told The Associated Press that Gaiser was not from Texas and had not gone through the state’s bipartisan judicial evaluation process. He separately told CBS News that Gaiser lacked trial experience. Cornyn also proposed Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey as an alternative, AP reported. Cornyn said he did not know whether Gaiser’s nomination would be formally withdrawn.
Sen. Ted Cruz defended the nomination, saying Gaiser was the only candidate he believed could be confirmed by the end of the year. Cruz warned that if the committee did not advance Gaiser, Democrats could leave the seat vacant after taking control of the Senate in January, AP reported.
The Justice Department described Gaiser as an “outstanding judicial nominee,” according to AP’s account of the department’s statement. Gaiser leads the department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which advises the president and executive branch agencies.
The Washington Sun reported that Cornyn shouted at Cruz on the Senate floor on Nov. 17; its reporters said they could not hear Cruz’s reply. The New Republic also reported the exchange, citing the Sun.
Gaiser’s Senate questionnaire says Cruz’s staff contacted him about the vacancy on Nov. 4. He said Cornyn’s staff spoke with him two days later, when the White House Counsel’s Office also told him he was under consideration.
