Elon Musk's X Faces Legal and Advertising Challenges Over Content Controversy

Elon Musk's company X, previously known as Twitter, has initiated a legal battle against Media Matters, a news organization, claiming defamation. This action follows a report by Media Matters showing ads from major companies like IBM and Apple adjacent to antisemitic content.

The Impact of the Media Matters Report

Last week, Media Matters published an article with evidence of ads from high-profile companies appearing next to harmful content on X. This revelation led to IBM and Apple withdrawing their advertisements from X, significantly impacting the company, which is already losing advertisers.

Elon Musk's Reaction and Lawsuit

Elon Musk expressed strong disapproval of Media Matters' report and announced his intention to sue the organization. The lawsuit, filed upon the opening of court, alleges that Media Matters fabricated the images showing the ad placements. X's lawsuit claims that Media Matters intentionally created these images to defame the company.

Contradictory Evidence from X

However, the lawsuit's claim that Media Matters manufactured these images seems to contradict statements from within X itself. CEO Linda Yaccarino admitted that a minimal number of users did see Apple's ad next to the contentious content, suggesting that the ad placements were not fabricated.

Content Moderation and Ad Placement on X

Media Matters' report highlighted how it set up conditions to display these ads by using an account with no ad filter and following accounts with hateful content along with corporate advertisers. The lawsuit admits that these accounts were known for extreme content but were not demonetized until after Media Matters' exposé. This raises questions about X's content moderation policies and the protection of brands from appearing next to such content.

Advertiser Withdrawal from X

The report's impact extended beyond the companies mentioned, as other major firms like Lionsgate, Warner Bros. Discovery, Paramount, and Sony also removed their ads from X. The lawsuit argues that this was a result of Media Matters' manipulation, but Lionsgate explicitly cited Musk's tweet as their reason for withdrawing.

Legal and Financial Implications for X

X's lawsuit, demanding $100,000 in damages and a jury trial, faces uncertainty in both its legal standing and potential outcomes. This situation reflects the complexities and challenges of moderating content on social media platforms and the repercussions it can have on advertiser relationships and company reputation.

Photo: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash