Microsoft Corp, Microsoft's GitHub Inc, and OpenAI Inc argued that a lawsuit against them for improperly monetizing open-source code in training artificial intelligence systems cannot be sustained for lack of specificity.
The companies said before a San Francisco federal court that the complaint by a group of anonymous copyright owners did not outline their allegations specifically enough.
Microsoft and OpenAI said the plaintiffs failed to raise what specific injuries they suffered from the companies' actions and that the lawsuit did not identify particular copyrighted works misused or contracts breached.
They added that GitHub's Copilot system, which suggests lines of code for programmers, made fair use of the source code.
A GitHub spokesperson for that the company has "been committed to innovating responsibly with Copilot from the start."
Two anonymous plaintiffs, who are seeking to represent a class of people who own copyrights to code on GitHub, insist that Copilot unlawfully reproduces their code.
.They said that the companies trained Copilot with code from GitHub repositories without complying with open-source licensing terms.
Open-source software can be modified or distributed for free by any users who comply with a license, which normally requires attribution to the original creator, a notice of their copyright, and a copy of the license, according to the lawsuit.
According to the complainants, Copilot's goal of replacing a huge swath of open source by taking it and keeping it inside a GitHub-controlled paywall violates the licenses that open-source programmers chose and monetizes their code despite GitHub's pledge never to do so.
Microsoft also said in its filing that the copyright allegations would "run headlong into the doctrine of fair use," which allows the unlicensed use of copyrighted works in some situations.


Brazil’s Supreme Court Orders Jair Bolsonaro to Begin 27-Year Prison Term
Asian Markets Mixed as Fed Rate Cut Bets Grow and Japan’s Nikkei Leads Gains
Intel Rejects TSMC’s Allegations of Trade-Secret Leaks as Legal Battle Escalates
Germany’s Economic Recovery Slows as Trade Tensions and Rising Costs Weigh on Growth
Norway’s Wealth Fund Backs Shareholder Push for Microsoft Human-Rights Risk Report
IMF Deputy Dan Katz Visits China as Key Economic Review Nears
Yellow Corp Reaches Major Settlement With Pension Plans Amid Ongoing Bankruptcy Case
Australia’s Economic Growth Slows in Q3 Despite Strong Investment Activity
U.S. Backs Bayer in Supreme Court Battle Over Roundup Cancer Lawsuits
Netflix Nearing Major Deal to Acquire Warner Bros Discovery Assets
U.S. Justice Department Orders Intensified Probe Into Antifa and Domestic Extremist Groups
Gold Prices Edge Higher as Markets Await Key U.S. PCE Inflation Data
Tunisian Opposition Figure Chaima Issa Arrested Amid Rising Crackdown
Samsung Launches Galaxy Z TriFold to Elevate Its Position in the Foldable Smartphone Market
UN General Assembly Demands Russia Return Ukrainian Children Amid Ongoing Conflict
YouTube Agrees to Follow Australia’s New Under-16 Social Media Ban
Microchip Technology Boosts Q3 Outlook on Strong Bookings Momentum 



