Two U.S. senators have raised serious concerns over Saudi Arabia's unchallenged bid to host the 2034 FIFA World Cup, citing human rights violations and labor exploitation. Democratic Senators Ron Wyden of Oregon and Dick Durbin of Illinois penned a direct letter to FIFA President Gianni Infantino, urging the organization to reconsider its imminent endorsement of Saudi Arabia as the tournament host.
Criticism Over Human Rights Abuses
The senators’ plea comes as FIFA prepares to finalize Saudi Arabia's selection on December 11, following an expedited nomination process perceived as favorable to the kingdom. Wyden and Durbin highlighted Saudi Arabia’s record on human rights, describing it as fundamentally at odds with FIFA’s stated values.
"Approving Saudi Arabia's bid this December endangers workers, athletes, tourists, and members of the press," the letter stated. The senators emphasized the nation’s ongoing repression of dissidents, LGBTQ+ discrimination, and labor abuses. These criticisms echo concerns voiced by NGOs and international organizations, including the United Nations.
Saudi Arabia's recent modernization efforts under its Vision 2030 initiative, while celebrated by some, have failed to address systemic human rights issues, according to critics. Labor rights violations remain a particular concern as Saudi Arabia will need to construct most of the 15 stadiums required for the World Cup. The senators argue that FIFA's endorsement could exacerbate these abuses, similar to issues seen during Qatar’s preparations for the 2022 World Cup.
FIFA’s Controversial Ties With Saudi Arabia
FIFA's growing relationship with Saudi Arabia has also drawn scrutiny. A sponsorship deal with Saudi state oil giant Aramco has raised questions about the organization's commitment to human rights. Furthermore, a human rights risk assessment by law firm Clifford Chance, commissioned by FIFA, has been criticized for lacking independence.
The report recommended cooperation with the International Labor Organization (ILO), but activists point out that global rights experts often face barriers to operating within the kingdom. Critics argue FIFA's alignment with Saudi Arabia undermines its credibility and contradicts its pledge to uphold inclusion and labor protections.
In their letter, Wyden and Durbin specifically called out these deficiencies. "Saudi Arabia has failed to address how it will uphold labor protections, press freedoms, and non-discrimination standards. FIFA must thoroughly reevaluate this ill-equipped World Cup bid and select a rights-respecting host country," the senators wrote.
Social Media Reaction
The senators' letter has sparked widespread discussion on social media, with users weighing in on FIFA's decision and Saudi Arabia's controversial bid. Here’s how netizens reacted:
- @GlobalRightsNow: "FIFA has abandoned its values if it backs Saudi Arabia for 2034. Human rights should matter!"
- @FootballFanatic23: "How can a country with such a record host the world's biggest sporting event? Disgraceful."
- @Peace4All: "The U.S. senators are right—this decision puts lives at risk. FIFA needs to listen!"
- @FIFAWatcher98: "It’s not just about soccer; it’s about setting global standards. This is a step backward."
- @SportsAndPolitics: "FIFA’s ties with Saudi oil money tell you everything you need to know."
- @HopefulAthlete: "Athletes deserve better. Hosting the World Cup should mean more than just deep pockets."